The person above you will pick a person (real or fictional, famous or not), and you will state that that person "...was voted..." and then you can continue with a "most likely" or other thing that can make sense, just be funny, be ironic or the opposite of what you'd think, or whatever.

Then you post the person that the next poster will describe as voted.  For exmaple,

Player 1
Heath...

Player 2
...was voted most likely to blame it on a chair squeaking.
Tonya Harding...

Player 3
...was voted most likely to call 911 for stubbing a toe.

Osama bin Laden...

Player 4
...was voted most likely to play Jenga with his toes.

Yoda was voted...

...most likely to do, not try.

Hannibal Lecter was voted...

The last person you want to meet face to face...

Fourlegged was voted...

most likely to quit ASWoT within a week.

Vixcis was voted...

most sexy and evil.

Bill Gates was voted...

...most likely to have a chip on his shoulder.

King Kong was voted...

...most likely to grow hair on his chest.

Bill CLinton was voted...

most likely to become impeached.

Al Capone...

...was voted worst criminal.

Jimi Hendrix was voted...

most likely to be in Williw's 5k post.

Jimmy Neutron was voted...