Starchaser:
I tend not to play in any game below Mature level, so Ive tried to avoid looking too closely at this thread but Douglas Adams, Gant/Naylor and Pratchett all in the same game? You are making this one hard to ignore, you know? Please dont add any Neil Gaiman as well or Ill be unable to resist the pull!
Gaiman tends to go slightly too dark for my tastes, but there might be some influence I guess. I don't have much experience with him though. I've read Good Omens, seen the Coraline animated movie and read both of his "children's stories" he did with Dave McKean ("The day I swapped my dad for two goldfish" and "The wolves in the walls") but that's about it. Planning to someday venture into his more famous comics. (Sandman? American Gods? Something like that?)
Anyway, I'm curious what keeps you from taking on games below the mature level? Maybe we can see what we can work out?
Hendell:
I think you have about triple the source material you want. There are wildly different and conflicting version of space sci fi that won't be helping, pick one and run with it or there will be more confusion than fun.
These aren't settings for me, but examples of what type of humor I'd like to see. I'm a fan of satire, so these all apply, but I realize there are underlying concepts. I'm more a fan of Pratchett's humanistic optimism than of Adam's uncaring cold nihilism, so that's a talk that we could have at the start of the game with those interested :)
The main thing I'm looking for with the examples is the kind of humor, not the underlying concepts. I'l probably borrow stuff for talking about the game from other things, like Fate's session zero stuff with the Issue aspects as a kind of tags of what we want to see. Depending on what kind of story the group is interested in we could see about what we focus on. Also, we're mainly playing a game, not actually writing a novel, since that would be above most people's skill level I think. I mean,
actual novels go through revisions and extensive rewriting.