Legend of the Five Rings
In reply to deadmanshand (msg # 7):
I prefer 4e's layout, duelling rules, and a number of other changed mechanics. I don't like 4e's weapons (it's as though they were forced to keep weapon stats after acknowledging they don't want weapon stats) or kata, but eh.
1e has the fact that they hadn't yet stripped away any of the original vision for rebalancing, correctness, or ease of use.
3e over-relies on free raises, and despite appreciating some of 3e's character options myself, I don't feel they're necessary to play those characters.