Here's what the Mature Games Policy says:
quote:
Mature games are games which have (as some minor portion of them) mature themes, strong language, drug use, and/or extensive violence. Mature games use the Mature Content flag to warn potential readers that some of the game material may be considered offensive. Despite this flag, Mature Games must remain suitable to all ages.
Adult games are games which have as part of their content graphic sex or graphic and gratuitous violence. Though their story and plot may be very strong and elaborate, they detail sex and/or gore in a way to which children and teens should not be exposed.
Note, for example, that it does not say "any violence", it says, "extensive violence"
As has been mentioned by one of the other Moderators, the Mature rating has less to do with the game's content, and more to do with tone - how that content is presented.
And, no, nobody has said you are restricted to "'Children's Hour'-level purity". It is possible to present violence, crime, drug use, and even sex, in a way which fits within the above guidelines - mainstream national newspapers do it every day.
As another Moderator has already said in this thread:
quote:
So long as the level of detail is no more than you could read in a mainstream newspaper, you would be fine either way.