Re: It pops back up when someone posts, yes?
In reply to facemaker329 (msg # 2):
Also, if the GM deletes it, it won't delete from your sticky list. It'll move to a new subsection for Deleted Games. If it's not on your list, it's highly likely that it was an accidental deletion.
Also, to find it quickly you can go to "User Preferences" (top left corner under the RPOL banner), "Manage the Games you Monitor" (middle right side under "Your Game and Forum Sticky List), then "Are you missing any games?" (at the bottom of the window [a link, not a button]).
This will bring up a list of games that have been removed from your sticky list recently, highlight the game, click "Add the Selected Games."