Hi all,

Here's a question:  why do so many GMs make game threads that are invisible to some of the players?  I mean, I understand the players' characters aren't there for the activities in these threads but it seems counterproductive to me from a game-success standpoint.

I think a successful game requires a good community between the players, and these sorts of threads don't build such community--they interfere with it.  Players who aren't in the threads can losr interest.  The game seems less active to them.  They're less engaged in what is going on.  Plus, these other threads are an opportunity for them to get to know the other players and their characters.  There can be OOC talk about that player's situation.  Players are more engaged in the story.  Tons of community-building opportunities!

a lot of times these individual threads can have some of the most in-depth writing, too, so other players can be inspired to up their game.  This is why I leave all the threads in my games open for all to read.  what do you guys think?  Is there any good reason to close them?

In reply to Machiara (msg # 1):

Well Meta-gaming can be somewhat controlled with private threads. And as you already stated it can be used to bar the story from those who are not at that location. But more importantly it allows said players to be double agents without your (as a player) knowledge and allows a more believable "lie" if they strecth the truth of a quest.

But if a GM does do this he should probally make sure he keeps all the players engaged. I have played in a few games that use threads based on the area/location (ie adventuring site) that are bared (for instance a private club, or secret society hangout) and others are public. I have enjoyed such games, but its not for everyone. Either are funny hats, but people still wear 'em.